Monday, November 9, 2009

Design Study 2 by Anthony Prentice

Introduction:
I decided to do my design study on some of the intriguing murals in Philadelphia. My tour is not so much of a circuit, as it starts you off at 17th and Green and ends inside of the Italian market. There was not so much of a reason to start at 17th and Green Street, as the mural that was originally there that I wanted to be a part of my study has been erased by the tearing down of a building, however there was still an equally interesting mural across the street from it. That being said, I wanted to end in the Italian Market because I feel thats one of the most interesting parts of Philadelphia, uniquely Philadelphia in fact (There are few open air markets left in the United States, none however as famous).

Map:





View Mural Art Philadelphia in a larger map

Communication:

Participants will use there cell phones and internet capable phones to blog about each mural they encounter. This is not so much about reading what is there about the mural, which is why there are no descriptions on any of the murals that you can pull up in the map. The way the participants interact is by making their own asumptions and narratives on the area through the use of an open source blog, much like a twitter or blogger account. The participant will view the murals as they go along, and send what they interpret of the mural to the site. How it makes them feel, what they think it does for the neighborhood, and the significance of the mural itself. Much like what they've done in the Toronto example, participants can either contribute, or take in, information about the mural. Very much like Wikipedia however not as patrolled and regulated.

Rules and Triggers:

Participants are encouraged to take their time and just follow the map, so there are not any rules such as only go up numbered streets or anything like we've done before. The walking tour is meant to take time, and people are able to go at their own pace. As far as trigger points, the Murals are all big enough that they can clearly be seen, therefore negating the need for any sort of trigger points other than the cross streets that are referenced in the map.

Narative:

The narrative for each place is in what others have contributed and what you can take from each mural. For example, when you look at the Wilt Chamberlain mural, you can read the interpretations that others have posted. You can also take time, step back, and make your own idea of the place around. There are no right or wrong narratives for this area. Factual information is not needed, just what the place does to you, how it moves you. These murals are meant for bringing meaning in and of themselves to the areas they occupy. Aside from urban rejuvanation, they are there as an art form, and the artist wants the people to take from that place an idea of that setting and that mural.

This whole Idea is meant to evoke a sense of urban pride in those around the city. Most of the time we drive by these works of art, barely taking notice of their meaning or importance in that area. I've even witnessed jokes about murals being in bad neighborhoods only. It's sad that people drive around and can't take in the beauty of what some of these murals represent, such as family, integration, and hope. Take some time, and look through some of the murals on the tour. Each trigger point on the map has pictures of the murals that are on the tour, and when one finishes the tour, they can take in the surrounding area of the Italian market and all that has to offer.

DESIGN STUDY #2 LIACOURAS WALK- A HISTORICAL WALK THROUGH TIME by JACOB WOOLF


View Design Study #2 Map- LIACOURAS WALK in a larger map


This walk will be an interactive and comprehensive view of the history of Liacouras Walk at Temple University from the early 20th century to present day. In the very beginning, the participants would text me on my cell phone saying they are ready to begin. When this happens, I would transfer them a list of voice recordings through MMS. Also, I would pix message them pictures of an old "Park Avenue" Atlas from 1904, as well as a recording describing that time period on LW.

What happens next is that each "trigger point" after this one has a historical picture of Liacouras walk, as well as the narration (which is on the participants' phone) relating to a particular time period and trigger point on the path. The trick is that these are sadly not in chronological order. The participants will have to, by using the narration as clues, at the end match up each picture and narration (numbered #1-#9) to its respective TIME PERIOD (as marked at each trigger point) in order to succeed, thus making it specific to each participant.

I should clarify. Here’s how it would play out. The participant walks up to the trigger point. They see a picture of that trigger point in some previous time in Temple’s history. They hear the narrative, which describes the time period of the picture and more importantly, its relation to images depicted in other pictures. For instance, one narration could say, “This is where Curtis Hall used to be before it was torn down to build Alter Hall. Curtis Hall was here before the kids gathered to speak about peace on Liacouras Walk, and even before the building of Founder’s Garden”. Then, in another narration, it could state, “This is Founder’s Garden. Founder’s Garden was built to commemorate Russell Conwell. It was built after Curtis and after color photos had already been popularized, but before LW was full of shops.” When they see the color picture, it will clue them in on where to place the picture of Founder’s Garden on the time line. This seems like it would be extremely difficult to match up, but even just by looking at the pictures you can gain and idea of when they are from based on cars/buildings.

With that in mind, I want to make it clear that there are a few choices I made specifically to convey meaning to the project. I wanted to make this walk seem like a trip through time, basically making the walkway a giant timeline. The choice to make the path not straight however comes from a couple of different reasons. The first reason is that most of the things that make Liacouras Walk what it is aren’t the walkway itself. Rather, it is the buildings that line it that tell a true story. The other more abstract reasoning behind it not being completely straight is that personally, I don’t see history as just a timeline. Rather, I see it as a crooked eternal path that takes us in several different directions. Some of these directions lead us in more severe ways than others however, which I have acknowledged by making the largest misdirection leading to Founder’s Park and the grave of Russell Conwell, for without him, Temple University would not exist today.

What I think is most interesting about my particular project is that its story is non-fiction, but still just as entertaining (at least in my opinion). I think it is fascinating to see how the same space has evolved over time, even just the past 100 years. What is even more fascinating is to think about the PEOPLE who inhabited these same places before us and how their actions shaped Temple into what it is today, but importantly, what they may have done to shape the world today. (Shout out to Bill Cosby)

Thusly, the narrator I chose to tell the story of Liacouras Walk was Carol Hamlin, who works at the Temple Archive, or Templar, where I got all of my pictures used for this project. I figured, hey who would better tell the story and history of this area better than the person who’s JOB it is to know about this area. She also was a really nice lady I think people would like to listen to. I also had the idea of having her at a couple of trigger points speaking of her own personal experience on Liacouras Walk. (These would both be added to the very end, and then would have to be figured out what time she was descrbing just based on the information…no pictures here.) I think by doing this it adds an ENTIRELY new level to the whole project, because when all is said and done, people are the ones who experience history, not the books in which they are written. The anecdotal aspect would also help solidify all the facts as a narrative, because we would be able to hear the experience of a real person in a different time period.

Furthermore, the reason I chose to make the participants put the timeline together themselves is because if it was just told to them in chronological order, it would just seem like a history text book. By making them participate in the creation of this giant timeline, it lets them participate in a form of art as well as participate in their own learning. This becomes apparent when they have to analyze the photos and documents in a way as to give them context without the pictures and documents screaming it in their face.

Because of the structure of this, with picking different times in history that are more general than specific, the overall “narrative” is more episodic than climactic, meaning it is merely telling of different events that are inter-related rather than all building up to one specific climax. However, while this seems like it would be more boring, I think the climax of the narrative is being able to match all of the pictures up correctly with their respective time period.

Here are the specific instructions for navigating Liacouras Walk during this:

1. Walk to the intersection of Liacouras Walk and Norris. Turn facing South.

2. Text Jake’s cell phone numbers saying you are ready to begin.

3. After receiving the pictures of the 1904 Atlas and narration voice recordings, make your way to the first trigger point, marked with a blue flag.

4. Once you have reached the trigger point, pick up the photo and play the recording. Take notes if you have to on specifics the narrator says to pick up on the time period.

5. When you reach the Seven Eleven, stop and read the news article. You can take this with you the rest of the way to help aid you when placing the items in chronological order.

6. Repeat Step #4 until you reach Montgomery Ave. Know some points will have more than one photo; that’s OK, just group them when applying them to a time period.

7. For the next step, you will have to take all the knowledge you know, and place the photos in order of their date taken, NOT the date built of the structures in the pictures. Since you know which narration goes with which photograph it should not be too difficult. Once you think you have put them in the correct order, dial Jake’s number and read off the order in which you placed them in by reading them off by the numbers on the back of the photos. You will be notified at this time whether or not you were successful.

8. BRAG TO YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT HOW MUCH YOU KNOW ABOUT FREAKIN LIACOURAS WALK. (I am not liable for the loss of friends).

Personally I think I have already assessed the project a couple times already, but I’ll formally do one now:

I would like to begin my assessment with the following Guy Debord quote: "All that was once directly lived has become mere representation." In my project, I think I prove this to be wrong. I say this because it refutes the idea that technology has made us unable to process human emotions without this medium of TV or movies. Now, while my project uses photographs, I think it is apparent how much interest and learning can come out of photos and historical evidence of a certain place. The documentation of these things it was draws us in and makes us feel emotions; it doesn’t stop it from happening. When you strip out the political motivations of movies and TV, and have someone like me who just wants people to learn about something objectively, technology is at its purest form: to simplify our life, not complicate it. In relation to the Janet Cardiff Readings, my project has a completely different style, but I think they both are effective. While hers is more expressionistic, mine is more expositional. While she wants to put you in the middle of this story she has created, my goal was to make you create your own story about the evolution of this great thing we have here at Temple University that has been the center of attention for so long.

Design Study 2

Trenton is not a very large city. One can easily navigate through the entire place in no time at all. The directions I took were inconvenient, but showed some interesting sites. The route I took is a unique route designed to portray all aspects of Trenton, NJ: the slums, the downtown, and areas of recreation, dinning, etc.

There are not so good areas of Trenton, but there are more areas that are nice. One can dine at one of the many restaurants while viewing the calm architecture of downtown which is dominated by clean bricks. The areas buildings are also influenced by the vast number of Catholic and Baptist churches in the region. Although the NJ Transit Center serves as a transportation station that I occasionally use to get to NYC, DC, or even here to Temple University, the facility was recently remodeled into an extremely prominent building with brilliant modern architecture that makes the place really stand out. The trains were also redone. My favorite place to eat is Matteo's Pizzeria, which is farther away from most of the excitement of the city. Not too far from the center city area is the Waterfront Park. I frequently visit this sports stadium which is home to the Trenton Thunder baseball team. My high school also held jazz performances outside of the stadium. Not far from Waterfront Park is a very large club called Kat Man Du. Both of these buildings attract large crowds every night, and are nice places to be especially at night because they are both right up against the Delaware river. Most areas along the river, in Trenton, are calm, relaxing, spots to chill out, fish, or just have a small picnic or something of that sort. Taking the boat out is also a fun thing to do. Anywhere you are on either side of the river, there are lots of places to see, restaurants to eat at, and fun things to do.

Trenton has lots of neat things to offer. There isn't just crime-infested neighbor-hoods where nobody wants to be. You can do a lot in this remarkably stereotyped city. Just like in Philadelphia, there are all sorts of structures that capture the interest, appetite, and recreation, of many people all day and all night. The river and the famous "Trenton Makes, The World Takes" bridge are very characteristic of this city which is alive as any other city at night time as well as during the day.


Rules and instructions.

Communicating was all made up of conversing with my friends and locals who helped us navigate around. We knew mostly where we were going, but it was interesting how there was such a diverse variety in the directions we were given by different people.

DESIGN STUDY #2 LIACOURAS WALK- A HISTORICAL WALK THROUGH TIME by JACOB WOOLF

Also special thanks to Carol Hamlin who basically helped me with ALL the info I got and used, including the pictures.

The embedding thing wasn't working out-so i attached a link here where the narrative is rough but i more explained then general idea of each trigger point so that it is understandable.

http://maps.google.com/maps?client=safari&rls=en&q=design%20study%202&oe=UTF-8&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wl


This walk will be an interactive and comprehensive view of the history of Liacouras Walk at Temple University from the early 20th century to present day. In the very beginning, the participants would text me on my cell phone saying they are ready to begin. When this happens, I would transfer them a list of voice recordings through MMS. Also, I would pix message them pictures of an old "Park Avenue" Atlas from 1904, as well as a recording describing that time period on LW.

What happens next is that each "trigger point" after this one has a historical picture of Liacouras walk, as well as the narration (which is on the participants' phone) relating to a particular time period and trigger point on the path. The trick is that these are sadly not in chronological order. The participants will have to, by using the narration as clues, at the end match up each picture and narration (numbered #1-#9) to its respective TIME PERIOD (as marked at each trigger point) in order to succeed, thus making it specific to each participant.

I should clarify. Here’s how it would play out. The participant walks up to the trigger point. They see a picture of that trigger point in some previous time in Temple’s history. They hear the narrative, which describes the time period of the picture and more importantly, its relation to images depicted in other pictures. For instance, one narration could say, “This is where Curtis Hall used to be before it was torn down to build Alter Hall. Curtis Hall was here before the kids gathered to speak about peace on Liacouras Walk, and even before the building of Founder’s Garden”. Then, in another narration, it could state, “This is Founder’s Garden. Founder’s Garden was built to commemorate Russell Conwell. It was built after Curtis and after color photos had already been popularized, but before LW was full of shops.” When they see the color picture, it will clue them in on where to place the picture of Founder’s Garden on the time line. This seems like it would be extremely difficult to match up, but even just by looking at the pictures you can gain and idea of when they are from based on cars/buildings.

With that in mind, I want to make it clear that there are a few choices I made specifically to convey meaning to the project. I wanted to make this walk seem like a trip through time, basically making the walkway a giant timeline. The choice to make the path not straight however comes from a couple of different reasons. The first reason is that most of the things that make Liacouras Walk what it is aren’t the walkway itself. Rather, it is the buildings that line it that tell a true story. The other more abstract reasoning behind it not being completely straight is that personally, I don’t see history as just a timeline. Rather, I see it as a crooked eternal path that takes us in several different directions. Some of these directions lead us in more severe ways than others however, which I have acknowledged by making the largest misdirection leading to Founder’s Park and the grave of Russell Conwell, for without him, Temple University would not exist today.

What I think is most interesting about my particular project is that its story is non-fiction, but still just as entertaining (at least in my opinion). I think it is fascinating to see how the same space has evolved over time, even just the past 100 years. What is even more fascinating is to think about the PEOPLE who inhabited these same places before us and how their actions shaped Temple into what it is today, but importantly, what they may have done to shape the world today. (Shout out to Bill Cosby)

Thusly, the narrator I chose to tell the story of Liacouras Walk was Carol Hamlin, who works at the Temple Archive, or Templar, where I got all of my pictures used for this project. I figured, hey who would better tell the story and history of this area better than the person who’s JOB it is to know about this area. She also was a really nice lady I think people would like to listen to. I also had the idea of having her at a couple of trigger points speaking of her own personal experience on Liacouras Walk. (These would both be added to the very end, and then would have to be figured out what time she was descrbing just based on the information…no pictures here.) I think by doing this it adds an ENTIRELY new level to the whole project, because when all is said and done, people are the ones who experience history, not the books in which they are written. The anecdotal aspect would also help solidify all the facts as a narrative, because we would be able to hear the experience of a real person in a different time period.

Furthermore, the reason I chose to make the participants put the timeline together themselves is because if it was just told to them in chronological order, it would just seem like a history text book. By making them participate in the creation of this giant timeline, it lets them participate in a form of art as well as participate in their own learning. This becomes apparent when they have to analyze the photos and documents in a way as to give them context without the pictures and documents screaming it in their face.

Because of the structure of this, with picking different times in history that are more general than specific, the overall “narrative” is more episodic than climactic, meaning it is merely telling of different events that are inter-related rather than all building up to one specific climax. However, while this seems like it would be more boring, I think the climax of the narrative is being able to match all of the pictures up correctly with their respective time period.

Here are the specific instructions for navigating Liacouras Walk during this:

1. Walk to the intersection of Liacouras Walk and Norris. Turn facing South.

2. Text Jake’s cell phone numbers saying you are ready to begin.

3. After receiving the pictures of the 1904 Atlas and narration voice recordings, make your way to the first trigger point, marked with a blue flag.

4. Once you have reached the trigger point, pick up the photo and play the recording. Take notes if you have to on specifics the narrator says to pick up on the time period.

5. When you reach the Seven Eleven, stop and read the news article. You can take this with you the rest of the way to help aid you when placing the items in chronological order.

6. Repeat Step #4 until you reach Montgomery Ave. Know some points will have more than one photo; that’s OK, just group them when applying them to a time period.

7. For the next step, you will have to take all the knowledge you know, and place the photos in order of their date taken, NOT the date built of the structures in the pictures. Since you know which narration goes with which photograph it should not be too difficult. Once you think you have put them in the correct order, dial Jake’s number and read off the order in which you placed them in by reading them off by the numbers on the back of the photos. You will be notified at this time whether or not you were successful.

8. BRAG TO YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT HOW MUCH YOU KNOW ABOUT FREAKIN LIACOURAS WALK. (I am not liable for the loss of friends).

Personally I think I have already assessed the project a couple times already, but I’ll formally do one now:

I would like to begin my assessment with the following Guy Debord quote: "All that was once directly lived has become mere representation." In my project, I think I prove this to be wrong. I say this because it refutes the idea that technology has made us unable to process human emotions without this medium of TV or movies. Now, while my project uses photographs, I think it is apparent how much interest and learning can come out of photos and historical evidence of a certain place. The documentation of these things it was draws us in and makes us feel emotions; it doesn’t stop it from happening. When you strip out the political motivations of movies and TV, and have someone like me who just wants people to learn about something objectively, technology is at its purest form: to simplify our life, not complicate it. In relation to the Janet Cardiff Readings, my project has a completely different style, but I think they both are effective. While hers is more expressionistic, mine is more expositional. While she wants to put you in the middle of this story she has created, my goal was to make you create your own story about the evolution of this great thing we have here at Temple University that has been the center of attention for so long.

Design Study 2. - Brian Panebianco

Skateboard Spot Tour

View places where average people would not care about but skateboarders see the terrain in a different way. Use an iphone to follow this path and find information about the trigger points you will encounter on the way. Also use the camera on your phone to take pictures of each spot you stop at to maybe post on a blog and document your trip, If you see any other places you think can be skated then take pictures of these spots too and maybe add your own trigger points to the map.


View Skateboard Spot Tour in a larger map

Walking Tour: Dolphin Research Center

Introduction:
The Dolphin Research Center in Grassy Key, FL is a place where humans study and interact with dolphins and other marine mammals, such as sea lions. They are a not-for-profit organization dedicated to research and education about dolphins and their natural environments. Many of the dolphins at the facility today were found injured, abandoned, or are descendants of dolphin actors.

My vision in this proposal is to allow visitors the chance to get a location-based education on the dolphins who live at the facility and to learn small pieces of information at each trigger point.

Element 1, Map:
This is a satellite view of DRC. Legend:
(waves) = lagoon
(camera) = photograph (all of which are mine)
(blue marker) = other points of interest


View DRC Walking Tour in a larger map

Element 2, Communication:
Guests at the Dolphin Research Center (DRC) often are there for a short time, visiting the Florida Keys from international locations. More involved programs such as interacting and swimming with dolphins take longer periods of time than many guests have during their stays. To create a narrative tour, I propose using the technology setup of iPod touch mobile communications devices and external cases with barcode scanners built in.

A guest can check out one of the iPod touch packages (iPod + external case + headphones) and walk leisurely around the facility. When a barcode sign is reached, the user may scan a barcode to hear an audio clip, see a photograph, watch a video, or read some text. All of these functions (scanning ability and pieces of media) will be stored within an application installed on the device, so no internet access is required. Audio will be played through the headphones, and video on the screen.

Element 3, Rules and Triggers:
The ability to take a leisurely tour somewhat negates the use of rules (aside from making sure the equipment package is undamaged) because of the nature of the setup. Visitors are encouraged to take their time and learn at whatever pace suits them. Signs clearly explain where the trigger points are, and barcodes are printed on them to allow tourists easy scanning to access the media features. Here is a mockup of what the signs might look like:



Trigger points will be set up at each of the lagoon locations marked on the map, to give a brief biography of each of the dolphins who live there, video shot of training or interactions, and short facts about dolphin behaviors or lives.

Element 4, Narrative:
The narrative I hope will evolve from this project is in line with the mission of the Dolphin Research Center and its spirit. The staff aims to educate and inform visitors by allowing them to interact with dolphins and providing informational sessions. I believe my proposed project will extend this concept into the technology age and allow for easier, more in-depth, and dynamic learning experiences as the facility evolves. Learning about the dolphin family and facts about behaviors of this animal will better educate the public and hopefully engender a deeper appreciation of nature at large.

Element 5, Assessment:
My narrative proposal makes use of the space by providing trigger points at designated locations going down the walkway between lagoons. Certain dolphins live in certain places, so it is a great way to learn about each animal, one or two at a time. My narrative allows visitors to gain a better appreciation of the place they are visiting, and the location is overlayed with an informal media presentation.

The Dolphin Research Center can be found online at http://www.dolphins.org/.

Design Study 2 - Michael Hearn

Communication Method:

I really think what is most appealing to locative narrative to me is the ability to show and share other people things you know or have experienced in this setting that they may have been walking through before or show them a specific side of it they haven’t even wandered through before. I want to express that as well as leave something for other people to find to keep on having people, even those who aren’t aware of the narrative, to find something. If there was no limit to simply planting stands in the ground with an attached notebook for people to write on and add to, that would be my suggestion. As is, the trigger points are anything you know about that was changed or have some history to it. This recalls Kaprow’s Happenings because it’s very based on audience interpretation and participation, because they can go on to add or shape the narrative a little more, as well as create their own. Maybe they could walk past the narrative and keep on going, still leaving notes on observations.

Map for this specific narrative:






Directions:

1. Start at 31st and Spring Garden. Walk across the bridge over the Schuylkill River to Art Museum Drive.

2. In the park closest to the river, go up the path to the gazebos.

3. Continue circling around the art museum until you reach the front.

4. Continue with the parks down Kelly Drive to Von Collns field, a field with two baseball diamonds. Walk alongside it until you reach a park near the Rodin Museum and walk around that to the right.

5. Continue down the Benjamin Franklin Parkway until you reach the Free Library. Take a left down 19th st. until you see a park on the right. Cross the park and arrive on the other side.

This narrative (co-relates to each direction number):

1. You’re around Penn campus and across from center city. As you walk across the bridge, you can see the murals of people painted on the bridge wall sides. These are actual people who have passed the bridge, painted by a mural foundation over a pre-existing mural. You can see train tracks below and a train track above the road.



2. This park is commonly used by bikers and joggers but maybe you see tourists or families here too. Over the side on the Schuylkill you can look and see a small path near the water with a statue. The gazebos overlooking the water are fairly new, replacing previous dilapidated gazebos and poles.



3. To the side of the art museum is a large abstract statue called the Iroquois. It's only been around for a couple of years (in fact, most of the online map software I looked at didn't have it on the satellite coverage), but it's been around long enough to feel strange when you discover something about it. Did you know the part in the middle actually swings back in forth?


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRfrM51VCUE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zCxfDji_mvM

4. This field was dedicated to the memory of a fallen police officer, a Sergeant of the Fairmount Park department, who was shot to death in 1970 by a radical group (who was later apprehended). The field has been commonly used for baseball games for kids and schools, and there’s even a playground for young children and families. Past the Rodin Museum is currently an empty field with a fence around it and signs saying it will be an extension of the Art Museum dedicated to specific artists. Before that, it was a Juvenile Center to jail delinquents, called the Youth Study Center. There were a lot of reports of kids being able to break out of there, apparently.



5. The final park on this map has a ditch beneath it full of overgrown shrubbery and grass. From 1976 to 1999 there was a train that ran along that ditch, the tracks are still there though no longer visible, and the train would run straight to the Philadelphia Inquirer over at 15th and Broad Street to deliver paper. The trains were run by the same company that used the train tracks you walked over at the bridge at the start, the Conrail company. They’re no longer in operations though the tracks remain and the space hasn’t been claimed yet.





Assessment:

I think, while cities obviously have plenty of history, Philadelphia is a pretty good choice for this narrative because there’s a lot of history and reshaping of the city that people could discuss or enlighten others about, and this specific path I chose I wanted to show some things, both of the past and the present, and how they’ve changed. Obviously the most significant pieces involved in the narrative and this project are the constructed pieces of the city around, not just buildings but the pathways and small constructs too. The narrative and notes will create specific experiences by allowing any and all personal knowledge to guide or inform the person experiencing the narrative, which can range from a whole variety of knowledge, whether personal or about the city’s history itself. As a result the place is very much part of the narrative, dedicated to it and shaping it as well as the narrative shaping the perceptions of the city in the eyes of the individual.